The plants fed by Fungi.ย
In a functioning society, everyone has their part to play. But there will always be some who find a way to cheat the system. Mycoheterophic plants do just that by hacking into the reciprocal system established between fungi and plants. Myco-mushroom, and heterotrophic – eating, describes the group of plants which get their food from mushrooms! Not directly, but through a long supply chain. Trees create carbon through photosynthesis, they pass that carbon through the mycorrhizal network to fungi, and the mycoheterotrophic plants get that carbon from the mycorrhizal network! But they do it all without lifting a finger. These plants take advantage of the honour code that trees and mushrooms have been abiding by for ever. Mycoheterotrophic plants release the same chemicals as other mycorrhizal plants, tricking fungi into letting them join the system.

I heard of these plants many times, but until recently, I had never seen one in real life. While hiking in Yunnan, China, I finally saw the unmistakable eerie white stem of a mycoheterotrophic plant, Hypopitys monotropa. Its common names include Dutch mans pipe, Pinesap and Yellow birds nest. Its name, one flower under pine, perfectly matched its environment. Hypo- under, and Pitys – pine shows that this plant is found growing under pine trees. Monotropa means โone turnโ and is in reference to the drooping flower of this plant.ย
These plants are easily identifiable by their colour. Regular plants, diverse and beautiful in their many greens, create carbon through the process of photosynthesis; turning the sun’s energy into food. This process is facilitated through the chlorophyll in their cells which gives plants their signature green colour. Mycoheterotrophs on the other hand, are absent of chlorophyll all together. (1)
They are not green, and they cannot make their own energy. Instead, they figured out millions of years ago that they could take advantage of an ancient carbon exchange system happening all around them. Why do it yourself, if someone else can do it for you? Mycorrhizal networks have been facilitating the influx of carbon from plant to fungal host for millennia. However, fungi are generally good team players and reciprocate this vital energy with other valuable resources like water and nutrients. Mycoheterotrophs skip returning the favour.

Hypopitys monotropa
The narrative around mycoheterotrophic plants always describes them as ungrateful parasites. But the literature shows a different story, one where fungi voluntarily form mycorrhizal connections with the germinating seeds of mycoheterotrophic plants. They are not coerced and the mystery as to whether there may even be a small degree of mutualism between the pair of organisms remains unsolved. (2) After all, it is thought that most mycoheterotrophic plants evolved from photosynthetic ancestors with symbiotic mycorrhizal relationships. (3) What if these plants are not exploiting fungi, but simply being nurtured by their fungal partner, on the back of symbiotic trust built over millions of years?
The mycorrhizal umbilical cord
Nature is all about balance. Under the forest soil, mycelium unspools like wool, over and under earthworms. These threads catch hands with fungi neighbours and link fingers with tree roots. Each of these handshakes is approved by a unique pass-code. There is a pouring of chemicals between both parties to say โhello! me again!โ . The roots and mycelium refer to their genetic blueprint which has logged each successful historic interaction in DNA, for millions of years. After recognition, root plant tissue is unlocked in trust and hyphal strands of mycelium grasp on, firm. This chain strings through the forest, heavy in knit and purl. A burlap both fine as silk and strong as timber. This is the mycorrhizal network, a legendary system run by fungi which connects the whole forest. Here, nutrients, water and energy are exchanged between participating residents. It is a delicate system of give and take. But what about those who just take?
Somewhere amongst the soil, a microscopic seed begins to stir. It sprouts, squirming in the soil with little roots and no shoots. It reaches blind and digging, trying to find a path forward. A rummaging mycelial thread senses its distress signal and with a shrug of recognition plugs in without much deliberation. Mycorrhizal connections can be formed from the first moments that a plant germinates. It is at these crucial times that fungi can be a plant’s lifesaving caretaker.
At the beginning of that plant-fungi relationship, the plant lacks sufficient capacity to photosynthesise and does not have much to give in return. This is the initial investment fungi make into the relationship. They are betting that later in their life when the plant grows strong and tall, the balance will strike an equilibrium, by reciprocating carbon to their mycorrhizal partner. The fungus is unaware that this time, things will be different.

The germinated seedling is now a helpless baby, latched and bound by umbilical cord to its mycelial mother. And where is the father? The trees down the line, busy perhaps photosynthesising to create food, and too distant to even know of the seeds existence. The tree provides the carbon to the fungal mother, who siphons morsels to the slow growing seed. Sugary water flows through these pipes, a circulatory system pumping to keep everyone alive.
As time passes, our mycorrhizal network grows and establishes connections with trees and other fungi across the sprawling forest. With arteries and tributaries, capillaries and streams, losing sight of each pathway is just part of doing business. Meanwhile, the mycoheterotrophic plant is silently holding on. A parasite, an appendage, a helpless embryo. It does not give anything back and quietly drains just a tiny bit of carbon from the wider system. Imagine a ship transporting tons of sugar across the ocean; if a stowaway rat steals a handful, no-one will ever notice.
The mycoheterotrophic plant is fully dependent on the network to survive. In a bid to go unnoticed she slurps silently only carbon that wonโt be missed. The mother, occupied with endless trade, has not noticed the loss. And the father has never seen the child he has fed grow up. After years of slow preparation, the time has come to evolve. This is a plant that spends most of its life in darkness, but its finale will eventually come in the form of metamorphosis. (2)
When the conditions are right, the plant will gather all its stored energy to unveil itself above ground. During one special time of year, mycoheterotrophs blossom into a reproducing flower. These flowers are hugely reduced when compared to a normal flower; often completely missing key anatomical features like leaves and petals. They generally just consist of one flower head, drooping with pollen, called the inflorescence.
Ready, she bows her head and unfurls, pushing through to the surface, burned by the sun not made for her translucent white tissue. She finds she is shaded by the tree canopy, meeting her makers, the sun farmers, face to face as strangers despite their physical underground bond. She is meek in the shadows of her ancestors with their thick green leaves reaching for the sun.
She has forgotten how. How to be green and how to grow alone. But she can take this moment as her own, to feed a butterfly her sweet pollen.


The plant parasite that looks like a mushroom
A thick mist lifts from the long spruce branches. The air is full of water even though this air is thin. Each water particle is suspended by pollen and spores, a dimension which we cannot see, but we can feel on our cheeks. Each inhale carries less oxygen than the one before, as we climb to over 3500m. I am in the mountains of Lijang, Yunnan, China. At this elevation, the rules are different and the ecology will happily show you how. The scene of fluffy spruce trees and fluffier moss is the definition of picturesque. The ground is equally shared with ferns, flowers and fungi. I feel like an elf, ducking under fallen logs and hoping over fairy pools. I am astounded by the colours nature has put on display here.ย

There stands a mushroom more brilliant than any I have seen before. Itโs a glistening red popsicle on a yellow stick and its cap is dusted with icing sugar. The strawberry head is laced with beaded pearls. But as I pause before it, I am confronted with the feeling that something doesnโt feel right. The fungus has an unusual texture, the cap is a peculiar shape and the colours just feel off. I reach my hand out to investigate this mystery further, expecting to pull the mushroom gently from the soil. Instead, a shiver travels down my spine as yanking the monster from the ground yields a โSNAP!โ, as the thing cracks like a stick of chalk in my hand. A clean break of crisp tissue and no fluffy mycelium in sight. Mushrooms do not snap like this, so I can confirm, we have an imposter.

Balanophora
The mushroom stipe is actually the fibrous stalk of a plant. Itโs shiny and smooth, like a stick of celery. The textured cap is just the flowering plants seeds. Digging deeper, I find a bulbous base, fat, crispy and covered in warts. The tuber bulges, full of precious starch. The whole thing is solid like a potato.
It may look like a mushroom, but it is definitely a plant. This is a species of Balanophora, a type of parasitic flowering plant. This plant lives not just by feeding from its host, but by growing completely intertwined with its host. Instead of just attacking its host, it manipulates it into becoming complicit in its dirty work. Balanophora induces the host plant to grow its own tissue into the tissue of the invading parasite. The host and the parasite become one. (4)
The tuber is a chimeric organ of host and parasite tissue. (6) This is different to most parasitic plants which penetrate the host with a growth known as a haustorium to steal nutrients. (5) Balanophora takes it a step further by mixing flesh to flesh, directly linking to the host’s vascular system. Linking up to internal wiring, a direct source for nourishment shared in tissue and shared in DNA.ย

The connection Balanophora has to its host runs even further than skin deep. More than 100 messenger RNAs originating from Balanophora are found in the roots of the host. (6) Messenger RNAs are specialised molecules that transcribe genes. That means, Balanophora pointedly turns on genes in its host, affecting what proteins are produced and how tissue will grow.
The mimic
To my right, I get deja vu. A true mushroom grows only inches away from the imposter, yet they look like twins! Despite matching colours, shapes and sizes, this one is not just fungaloid, but a true fungus! They are remarkably similar even down to the white frills bordering the cap. On Balanophora, these white tassels are the flower’s pollen. On the mushroom, this is remnant tissue from younger growth. This is an Amanita mushroom, similar to the famous Amanita muscaria, fly agaric, except this one has a bit more flair with warm summery colours, most likely being Amanita rubrovolvata.

How can they look so similar, yet be so different? One is a plant and one is a mushroom; meaning they are not even in the same Kingdom. I was not the first to see a resemblance between a species of Balanophora and mushrooms, as evident by the name Balanophora fungosa for a different species of Balanophora!
How did we get here? Why does a plant look so much like a mushroom? We can find an elegant answer in this plant’s evolutionary history. The distant ancestors of Balanophora would have looked and acted much more plant-like. Growing roots, shoots and creating its own energy from the sun through photosynthesis. Over many generations Balanophora slowly turned to a life of parasitism. Eventually, it became a holoparasite – a plant which is fully dependent on its host.

This type of parasitism may seem like an easy life, but to make this lifestyle work you must make serious sacrifices. Like a backpacker traveling overland – the less weight you carry and the more minimalist your gear is – the simpler and cheaper everything will be (speaking from experience!). When youโre on a budget, you must tread lightly, use your energy efficiently and you simply do not have room for unnecessary items. That dress you only wear sometimes? Out. That pair of shoes that donโt fit you anymore? Bin. Next thing you know, your backpack is light and you fade into the crowd skipping into the sunset.
Well, Balanophora is the same. In the pursuit of fully dependent parasitism, a mass shedding needed to occur. And, over millions of years, Balanophora lost an enormous 28% of its genome. (6) Balanophora has fully lost its ability to photosynthesis, it doesn’t have a typical root system, and lacks any stomata. This has affected its molecular repertoire too, with loss of genes for common secondary metabolite synthesis and metabolic functions.
Balanophora is truly a minimalist icon. Throughout this loss, there has also been gain. The baffling thing about Balanophora is that in the pursuit to manipulate its host, it started to become more like its host. Balanophora began collecting host genes for itself, and adding these foreign genes to its own arsenal. This is a phenomena known as horizontal gene transfer and is very rare in the plant world. (5,6)
While some functions have been lost completely, some have simply been outsourced. For example, Balanophora has lost all of its ABA biosynthesis genes despite abscisic acid being essential for growth and stress response. (6) It is likely that Balanophora is taking ABA directly from its host by asking its host to make a surplus. In the tubers of Balanophora, which is a gateway between host and parasite, host genes that produce ABA have been unregulated.
Copycat or Convergent Evolution
On the path to slimming down, Balanophora lost most of its physical characteristics, too. It shed its leaves and its roots until it was stripped bare. And with each plant characteristic lost, it began to morph into something closer resembling a mushroom. That has led to this beautiful example of convergent evolution. The phenomenon of two unrelated species independently developing similar traits, due to similar environmental pressures.
Balanophora spends the majority of its life cycle underground and comes to the surface for one purpose only – to reproduce. There is another group of organisms that do this alsoโฆmushrooms! And it turns out when it comes to maximizing your reproductive ability while minimizing excess baggage, fungi have it all figured out. Ultimately, through convergent evolution, that leads to the inflorescence (the flower) of Balanophora looking remarkably similar to the fruiting body of a mushroom.

Balanophora has mimicked the way fungi spread into new parts of the forest. Like the microscopic spores produced in the millions by mushrooms, Balanophora produce some of the smallest known seeds, at only 7ug per seed. They grow long and tall to maximise the distance their seeds can disperse, much like the strategy deployed by mushrooms.
We can see another example of this theory of convergent evolution with another parasitic plant species, Cynomorium. This is a desert parasitic plant that has also become hugely reduced on its path to parasitism. Its common names such as Maltese fungus and Maltese mushroom, show once again its similarities in appearance to fungi! Yet this time, under hot and arid environmental pressures, it ended up closely resembling desert fungi. Putting photos of Cynomorium coccineum side by side with desert fungi like Podaxis pistillaris and Phellorinia herculeana gave me so much satisfaction! The similarities are undeniable.

Image: Cynomorium coccineum 2.jpg by Hans Hillewaert, licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/) via Wikimedia Commons.


To be seen or to be hidden?
But why this mushroom? I began to wonder whether it was possible that these two species, the Amanita mushroom and the Balanophora plant, were interacting in any way. After all, Amanitaโs are mycorrhizal, meaning they form connections with trees. Is it possible that Balanophora is parasitising a tree that is also connected to this Amanita? Could the sharing of chemicals, nutrients and even RNA fragments stretch to the mycelium network?ย
Unfortunately, no one currently has an answer to this question. There are some trees that Balanophora parasitises that are ectomycorrhizal, such as Willow (salix). But this hypothesis has yet to be tested in Balanophora specifically. But despite these two being neighbours, and looking bizarrely similar in appearance, itโs likely they donโt say hi to each other often even if they were connected to the same tree. This is because Balanophora generally parasitises its host at roots closer to the tree trunk, in contrast fungi which make their connections on the root tips.
Itโs possible that the similarities in colour have an ecological benefit that we are yet to understand. Red is a strong colour that usually serves a deliberate purpose. Red is often associated with attracting birds for seed dispersal, but usually only in maturity. Since these plants are red all the time, it could also be acting as a deterrent, indicating to animals that it is not suitable for consumption. Of course both can be true at once, or maybe neither – only future ecological research can tell.
We donโt know what we donโt know
Two plants with completely different stories, but that both seem to be cheating the system. It takes both these plants an incredible amount of effort to produce their flowers. With humans around, it does not matter how effective your evasion camouflage is, or how unappetising your look, those flowering efforts can be in vain. The strange appearance of parasitic and mycoheterotrophic plants usually signals something completely different to us; a unique plant means unique medicinal compounds. Both these plants have been used widely in traditional medicine. Common names like crystal orchid and Snake fungus in China hint at the local recognition of these wonderful plants.
These plants only flower once a year, before they die completely. That means you never know where and when they will pop up each year. I feel incredibly lucky to have seen them not only in bloom, but also at the same time as such a highly similar mushroom. If you are lucky enough to see them too, please leave these delicate organisms alone to flower. Appreciate how much work and evolution it took for them to make it here.
In final words, Iโll share a quote from a conversation I had with the wonderful Trevor Padgett in reference to Balanophora. Thanks Trevor for sharing your wisdom on this bizarre plant.
the beautiful part of studying parasitic plants is that there are so many unknowns, and it feels like there are so many fascinating questions to explore; the horrible part of studying parasitic plants is that there are so many unknowns, and there are so many questions people have not yet asked ๐
Thank you for reading! I hope you enjoyed this exploration of how plants and fungi can interact in unexpected ways. One of the reasons why I have always loved biology is how it invites you to question why things are the way they are. Finding both this mycoheterotrophic plant and this species of Balanophora set me into a frenzy of questions. I had a blast jumping in the rabbit hole in search for answers.
Special thanks to Trevor Padgett for your insights and sharing of knowledge in this emerging field of plant science. Also special thanks to Dr. Xiaoli Chen, for sharing with me your fascinating work on Balanophora genomes and coevolution. I am so grateful for your help.
References
- Merckx, Vincent. (2013). Mycoheterotrophy: An Introduction. 10.1007/978-1-4614-5209-6_1.ย
- Martine, Christopher & Hale, Alison. (2015). Parasitism disruption a likely consequence of belowground war waged by exotic plant invader. American Journal of Botany. 102. 1-2. 10.3732/ajb.1500025.ย
- Waterman, Richard & Klooster, Matthew & Hentrich, Heiko & Bidartondo, Martin. (2013). Species Interactions of Mycoheterotrophic Plants: Specialization and its Potential Consequences. 10.1007/978-1-4614-5209-6_7.ย
- Rai, Ishwari & Adhikari, Bhupendra & Rawat, Gopal. (2014). A Rare and Endangered Root Parasite: Balanophora Involucrata Hook. F.& Thompson. Indian Forester. 140. 435-436.
- Thorogood, C.J., Teixeira-Costa, L., Ceccantini, G., Davis, C. and Hiscock, S.J. (2021), Endoparasitic plants and fungi show evolutionary convergence across phylogenetic divisions. New Phytol, 232: 1159-1167. https://doi.org/10.1111/nph.17556
- Chen, X., Fang, D., Xu, Y. et al. Balanophora genomes display massively convergent evolution with other extreme holoparasites and provide novel insights into parasiteโhost interactions. Nat. Plants 9, 1627โ1642 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41477-023-01517-7
- Min, S., Chang-Qin, Z., Yong-Peng, M. et al. Mycorrhizal features and fungal partners of four mycoheterotrophic Monotropoideae (Ericaceae) species from Yunnan, China. Symbiosis 57, 1โ13 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13199-012-0180-4
- Hynson, Nicole & Madsen, Thomas & Selosse, Marc & Adam, Iris & Ogura-Tsujita, Yuki & Roy, Mรฉlanie & Gebauer, Gerhard. (2013). The Physiological Ecology of Mycoheterotrophy. 10.1007/978-1-4614-5209-6_8.ย
- Eberwein, R., Nickrent, D.L. and Weber, A. (2009), Development and morphology of flowers and inflorescences in Balanophora papuana and B. elongata (Balanophoraceae)โ . American Journal of Botany, 96: 1055-1067. https://doi.org/10.3732/ajb.0800289
- In conversation with the wonderful Trevor Padgett, currently studying the complex world of Balanophora in Taiwan.







No comments yet.